福尔马林固定组织SNP与STR检测的比较

目的检测经长期福尔马林固定的组织降解情况,并比较组织中SNP与STR的检出率。方法本文对24例经福尔马林固定、-20℃保存5年的组织样本,采用Quantifiler?Trio DNA定量试剂盒检测样本DNA的降解系数及浓度,运用55-SNPs SNa Pshot复合分型体系和Power Plex?21试剂盒分别进行SNP与STR检测。结果大部分样本降解系数在1~8,发生不同程度的降解。与未降解样本相比,SNP分型完全一致,检出率为100%;其中8例样本STR分型存在33个等位基因丢失,降解系数均大于2.6,且75.8%的等位基因片段长度大于300bp。当样本检测出16个STR基因座时,似然率与54个SNP相当。当样本检出大于17个STR时,似然率大于54个SNP。STR基因座片段长度与等位基因检出率之间呈负相关。除2例样本降解系数较小却发生等位基因丢失外,其余样本降解系数与等位基因检出率之间呈负相关。结论经福尔马林长期固定的组织DNA易降解,检测SNP明显优于STR,但需要更多的SNP以提高个体识别能力。

Comparison of detection of SNP and STR in formalin-fixed tissue

Objective The purpose of this study was to detect the degradation degree of long-term formalin fixed tissue and to compare the detection rate of STR with SNP. Methods DNA was extracted from 24 formalin-fixed tissues stored at -20 ℃ for five years, and the concentration and degradation index of DNA was quantified with Quantifiler? Trio DNA Kit. A 55-SNP multiplex SNaPshot assay and PowerPlex? 21 system were used to amplify SNP and STR loci, respectively. Results The results showed that the degradation indexes of 24 specimens were ranged from 1~8. The SNP genotypes of the 24 specimens were completely consistent with the non-degraded DNA from the same individuals and the successful genotyping rate was 100%. However, 33 allele dropouts were observed with STR genotyping in 8 samples, of which the degradation index was higher than 2.6, and the fragment size of the 75.8% allele was longer than 300bp. The likelihood ratio based on 16 typable STR loci in the sample was close to that onthe basis of 54 SNPs. However, likelihood ratio based on more than 17 STR loci was over that accord to 54 SNPs. There was a negative correlation between the fragment size of STR and the allele detection rate, and a negative correlation also observed between the degradation index of samples and the allele detection rate except for two samples with mild degradation. Conclusion This study validated that the long-term formalin-fixed tissues were susceptible to degradation, and the SNP was more suitable for detecting these tissues than STR typing system. However more SNP loci are needed to test in order to increase the discrimination power.