知识产权诉讼中的鉴定人制度探析

知识产权诉讼中的鉴定人应定位成类似于专家证人的法官辅助人。其资质的认定应以鉴定权主义为原则,鉴定人主义为例外。当事人和法院均对鉴定人有选任权,但法院对当事人所选定的不合资质的鉴定人有否决权。其权利义务除遵循我国相关法律法规外,宜吸纳英美法系某些关于专家证人的义务规定。其鉴定意见须经法庭质证,由法官对鉴定意见的可采性做出判断。其责任追究应采用过错原则,错鉴责任的过错须是主观故意或重大过失。

Research on the Appraiser System in Intellectual Property Litigation

An appraiser in intellectual property litigation should be defined as judge assistant similar to expert witness.On his qualification authorization,the appraisal right doctrine should be the principle,whereas the appraiser doctrine is the exception.Both the litigants and court have the right to choose appraiser,however,the court can reject an unqualified appraiser chosen by litigants.The regulations about rights and duties of appraisers can be borrowed from the related rules on expert witness in Anglo-Americ...