以刑制罪:刑法教义学与刑事政策学相互贯通的路径选择

刑法教义学与刑事政策之间不仅是宏观的关系构造,还有微观的勾连论证,尤其是后者,在风险社会背景下具有更加重要的理论价值和实践意义。刑法刑事政策化是我国刑法教义学的发展方向,为了推动刑法教义学与刑事政策从相互隔离到相互融通,就需要在刑法理论上为政策要素进入刑事教义学构建合适路径。在消弭刑法教义学与刑事政策学李斯特鸿沟的过程中,以刑制罪司法逻辑具有特殊的价值和意义。

Charges Subjecting to Penalty: A Path Selection of Interpenetration between the Criminal Law Dogmatics and Criminal Policies

The criminal law dogmatics and criminal policies have not only macroscopic structural relations but also micro connections, and the latter in particular has more important theoretical value and practical sig- nificance in the context of risk society. The developing direction for the criminal law dogmatics in China is from criminal law to criminal policy, and in order to promote the criminal law dogmatics and criminal policy from isolation to accommodation, it is necessary to establish a proper path to insert the policy dements into dogmatics of criminal law. In the alleviation of Liszt gap between the criminal law dogmatics and the criminal policy, the judicial logic of charges subjecting to penalty has special value and significance.