论地方行政立法后评估中的合法性评价

如今地方行政立法的后评估既包含实效性分析,也包含了合法性评价。然而,合法性评价与合法性审查属不同的概念而不能简单移植。鉴于行政立法的合法性问题应在制定和实施阶段得以解决以及合法性评价在后评估中有被异化的可能,参考国外的实践并出于维护法制稳定的理念,可以认定合法性评价在地方行政立法后评估中的非必然性。

On Legitimacy Judgment during Post-evaluation of Local Administrative Legislation

Nowadays the post-evaluation of local administrative legislation covers both the study on effect and judgment of legitimacy,and yet the legitimacy judgment can't simply invoke the review of legitimacy because they are different after all.It can be concluded that the legitimacy judgment during post-evaluation of local administrative legislation is dispensable,as the question of legitimacy of administrative legislation should be settled in the phase of establishment and enforcement,as the legitimacy judgment during postevaluation may be dissimilated yet,and with the addition of the lesson from overseas practice and the consideration of legal stability.