刑事证据视野下的具体行政行为探究

刑事诉讼中对具体行政行为的证据审查,应基于刑事证据审查标准,合理尊重其公定力,形式审查为主,以审慎态度进行实质审查,并把握不以司法裁判代替行政意志之基本原则。基于对公平正义及司法独立价值的追求,刑事诉讼中,对具体行政行为证据效力的否定,不受该行政行为是否被撤销所羁束,司法机关有权以查明的事实,据实认定。

On Specific Administrative Act from A Perspective of Criminal Evidence

In criminal action the examination of the evidence of a specific administrative act should be based on criminal evidence censorship standards,respecting the presumptive legality,examing substantively,and abiding by the basic principle that judicial judgment can not replace administrative volition.For the sake of fairness and justice and judicial independence,in criminal action,the denial of the evidence validity of a certain specific administrative act should not be restricted to whether the administrative behavior is revoked.Instead,the judicial departments should have the authority to determine the facts.