共查询到20条相似文献,搜索用时 218 毫秒
1.
Why Should Remorse be a Mitigating Factor in Sentencing? 总被引:1,自引:1,他引:0
Steven Keith Tudor 《Criminal Law and Philosophy》2008,2(3):241-257
This article critically examines the rationales for the well-settled principle in sentencing law that an offender’s remorse
is to be treated as a mitigating factor. Four basic types of rationale are examined: remorse makes punishment redundant; offering
mitigation can induce remorse; remorse should be rewarded with mitigation; and remorse should be recognised by mitigation.
The first three rationales each suffer from certain weaknesses or limitations, and are argued to be not as persuasive as the
fourth. The article then considers, and rejects, two arguments against remorse as a mitigating factor in sentencing: that
the crime, not the offender, is the focus of punishment; and that the truly remorseful offender would not ask for mitigation.
The article concludes with a brief consideration of whether a lack of remorse should be an aggravating factor.
相似文献
Steven Keith TudorEmail: |
2.
Offender profiling postulates that crime scene behavior should predict certain offender characteristics. The aim of this study
is to investigate the relationship between offender characteristics, situational factors, and body disposal patterns. Sequential
logistic regression analysis on a sample of 85 sexual murderers shows that those who were in a relationship at the time of
the crime and who present organized psychological characteristics are more likely to move the victim’s body after the homicide.
However, when the victim is older and a conflict with the offender occurred prior to the crime, the body is more likely to
be left at the crime scene. Implications for offender profiling are discussed in light of the results.
相似文献
Eric BeauregardEmail: |
3.
Richard L. Lippke 《Criminal Law and Philosophy》2008,2(3):259-268
Steven Tudor defends the mitigation of criminal sentences in cases in which offenders are genuinely remorseful for their crimes.
More than this, he takes the principle that such remorse-based sentence reductions are appropriate to be a ‘well-settled legal
principle’—so well settled, in fact, that ‘it is among those deep-seated commitments which can serve to test general theories
as much as they are tested by them’. However, his account of why remorse should reduce punishment is strongly philosophical
in character. He sets to one side the many practical difficulties in implementing such reductions in the real world of criminal
justice institutions so that he can focus on the question of whether a plausible account of sentencing can show that remorse
should mitigate punishment. I contend that Tudor’s defense of such reductions is unpersuasive in certain respects. Yet even
if it can be made more persuasive, I argue that the conditions that would have to be satisfied for remorse-based sentence
reductions to be justifiably implemented are so many and various that they would likely exceed our abilities to responsibly
grant them in real world legal contexts. I therefore claim that Tudor has failed to provide a defense of the ‘remorse principle’
that serves to explain or justify existing legal practices.
相似文献
Richard L. LippkeEmail: |
4.
Causeless complicity 总被引:1,自引:1,他引:0
Christopher Kutz 《Criminal Law and Philosophy》2007,1(3):289-305
I argue, contrary to standard claims, that accomplice liability need not be a causal relation. One can be an accomplice to
another’s crime without causally contributing to the criminal act of the principal. This is because the acts of aid and encouragement
that constitute the basis for accomplice liability typically occur in contexts of under- and over-determination, where causal
analysis is confounded. While causation is relevant to justifying accomplice liability in general, only potential causation
is necessary in particular cases. I develop this argument through the example of the role of U.S. legal officials in abetting
the acts of unlawful interrogation that have taken place since 2001. I also suggest that there may be a limited justification
for ex post ratificatory accomplice liability.
相似文献
Christopher KutzEmail: |
5.
Recent research has demonstrated that burglary clusters in space and time, resulting in temporal changes in crime hotspot
patterns. Offender foraging behavior would yield the observed pattern. The offender as forager hypothesis is tested by analyzing
patterns in two types of acquisitive crime, burglary and theft from motor vehicle (TFMV). Using a technique developed to detect
disease contagion confirms that both crime types cluster in space and time as predicted, but that the space–time clustering
of burglary is generally independent of that for TFMV. Police detections indicate that crimes of the same type occurring closest
to each other in space and time are those most likely to be cleared to the same offender(s), as predicted. The implications
of the findings for crime forecasting and crime linkage are discussed.
相似文献
Shane D. JohnsonEmail: |
6.
Why We Punish in the Name of Justice: Just Desert versus Value Restoration and the Role of Social Identity 总被引:3,自引:1,他引:2
Two different notions of justice might motivate people to demand punishment of an offender. The offense could be seen as lowering
the victim’s and community’s status/power position relative to the offender, requiring a degradation of the offender to restore
a moral balance (just desert). Or, the offense could be seen as questioning community values, requiring a reaffirmation of
those values through social consensus (value restoration). Two studies referring to tax evasion and social welfare fraud yielded
supportive evidence. Just desert was related to traditional punishment, especially when participants did not identify with
a relevant inclusive community (Australians). Value restoration was related to alternative (restorative) punishment, especially
when community values were regarded as diverse and requiring consensualization. It tended to be related to traditional punishment
when community values were regarded as clear and consensual.
相似文献
Michael WenzelEmail: |
7.
This review paper seeks to explore some of the reasons why rehabilitation programs for male perpetrators of domestic violence
appear to be less effective in reducing recidivism than programs for other offender groups. It is argued that while the model
of systems response to domestic violence has predominated at the inter-agency level, further consideration might be given
to way in which men’s intervention groups are both designed and delivered. It is concluded that the program logic of men’s
domestic violence programs is rarely articulated leading to low levels of program integrity, and that one way to further improve
program effectiveness is to incorporate some of the approaches evident in more general violence prevention programs and from
what is know about good practice in general about offender rehabilitation.
相似文献
Andrew DayEmail: |
8.
Comparative studies of crime have persistently challenged and daunted criminology scholars. For criminologists studying Japan,
interest has traditionally been focused on the country’s much-heralded low crime rate. The current study examines white-collar
lawbreaking in both the United States and Japan, focusing on similarities and differences in culture, law, criminal justice
system response, corporate governance, and regulation. The study concludes that if Japan’s low crime rate is an enigma to
criminologists, then its ample amounts of white-collar and corporate crime appear that much more puzzling. Given that the
depth of the problem of white-collar crime goes far beyond adjudicated cases, Japan’s remarkably low rate of common crime
is likely eclipsed by its rate of white-collar and corporate crime. The study concludes that the different legal and cultural
contexts of the “law in inaction” go far in explaining the official nonrecognition of white-collar and corporate crime in
both the United States and Japan.
相似文献
Henry N. PontellEmail: |
9.
Peter Westen 《Criminal Law and Philosophy》2007,1(3):307-326
Commentators have contested the role of resulting harm in criminal law since the time of Plato. Unfortunately, they have neglected
what may be not only the best discussion of the issue, but also the first—namely, Plato’s one-paragraph discussion in the
Laws. Plato’s discussion succeeds in reconciling two, seemingly irreconcilable viewpoints that till now have been in stalemate.
Thus, Plato reconciles the view, that an offender’s desert is solely a function of his subjective willingness to act in disregard
of the legitimate interests of others, with the view that criminal sentences can appropriately be made to depend upon how
indignant, angry, and upset society is at an offender based upon the results of his culpable conduct. In doing so, Plato casts
light on retributive theories of punishment by suggesting that an adjudicator can be committed to retribution and yet rightly
believe that it is inappropriate to give an offender the full punishment he deserves. He also lays a basis for the view that
causation, rather being predicates for the just punishment of offenders toward whom the public is intuitively angry for harm,
is the consequence of the public’s being intuitively angry at offenders for harm.
相似文献
Peter WestenEmail: |
10.
Carrol Clarkson 《Law and Critique》2007,18(3):361-374
This paper explores the implications of uses of the word ‘we’ in post-apartheid South African fiction. ‘We’ in these novels
is typically a contested linguistic site – which tells of the loss of inherited communities, and reflects the ethically complex
negotiations of a ‘we’ perhaps still to come. Yet if the internal narratives assert a loss of community, each event of the
novel’s being-read inaugurates a new ‘community’ of readers. The paper considers the ethical implications of the act of reading
a literary text in post-apartheid South Africa. In the course of the argument, I draw links between African philosophies of
community, and Jean-Luc Nancy’s proposition that ‘I’ does not precede ‘we’. Thus I suggest some ways in which philosophies
from Africa contribute towards current debates about ‘we’ in contemporary continental philosophy.
相似文献
Carrol ClarksonEmail: |
11.
The Silence of the Lambdas: Deterring Incapacitation Research 总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1
This essay provides an economist’s perspective on criminological research into incapacitation effects on crime. Our central
argument is that criminologists would do well to substantially scale back the enterprise of trying to estimate the various
behavioral parameters central to a micro-level approach to measuring incapacitation effects, including the annual rate of
offending outside of prison (λ) and the lengths of criminal careers. One problem with this line of research is practical:
for example, mean estimates of self-reported criminal activity by incarcerated prisoners are quite sensitive to reports by
the most criminally active offenders. But the larger concern is conceptual—the incapacitation effects from a given change
in sentencing policy may be undermined by the possibility of replacement effects, and at the same time omit other benefits
that may arise from deterrent effects on crime. A more promising approach is to identify plausibly exogenous changes in sentencing
policy in order to estimate the net impact on crime from the combined effects of incapacitation, deterrence and replacement.
相似文献
Jens LudwigEmail: |
12.
Richard Rosenfeld 《Journal of Experimental Criminology》2006,2(3):309-319
The National Research Council’s report on evaluating anticrime programs contains sensible suggestions for improving evaluation
research in criminal justice but neglects the important role of substantive theory in linking evaluations of anticrime initiatives
to variation in crime rates across time and place. A working knowledge of crime rates is essential for designing and evaluating
anticrime programs. This essay calls for the development of a policy evaluation infrastructure that would support the continuous
monitoring of crime rates, generate knowledge of crime-producing conditions, and link evaluation research findings to one
another and to expected policy outcomes, notably crime reduction.
相似文献
Richard RosenfeldEmail: |
13.
Joan Petersilia 《Journal of Experimental Criminology》2008,4(4):335-356
Criminologists bemoan their lack of influence on U.S. crime policy, believing that the justice system would be improved if
their research findings were more central in decision making. I had an opportunity to test that notion as I participated in
California’s historic attempt to reform its prisons over the past 4 years. I became an embedded criminologist, where I was able to observe and contribute to the inner workings of state government. This article reports on my accomplishments
with respect to fostering research activities and shifting the department’s focus towards prisoner reintegration. It discusses
some of the lessons I learned, including the personal toll that such work entails, the importance of the timing of policy
initiatives, and the power of rigorous methodology and clear communication. I conclude by recommending that other policy-oriented
criminologists seek out similar experiences, as I believe our academic skills are uniquely suited and ultimately necessary
to create a justice system that does less harm.
相似文献
Joan PetersiliaEmail: |
14.
A substantial body of empirical research examines how the huge expansion in incarceration in the United States since the early
1970s has influenced crime. These studies merge the effects of three conceptually distinct paths by which incarceration might
reduce crime: general deterrence, specific deterrence and incapacitation. This issue of the Journal focuses specifically on
the incapacitation path. This Introduction reviews the individual papers and offers the editors’ judgment as to the plausibility
of progress using different research strategies. It emphasizes the potential for using individual level data to take advantage
of natural experiments.
相似文献
Peter ReuterEmail: |
15.
The purpose of this article is to provide an overview of a form of violence that represents a potential barrier to the development
of a nonviolent criminology. Using several contentions drawn from Emile Durkheim’s theory of crime and punishment, it is proposed
that persuasive arguments entail a component of violence where they contradict strong collective sentiments. The general nature
and normality of this form of violence are outlined. In addition, it is suggested that although neglect of this violence may
allow progressive researchers to maintain nonviolent self-conceptions, such neglect also may serve the interests of “intellectuals”
while undermining the power of “nonintellectuals.” The violence of persuasive argument thus constitutes a problematic paradox
for scholars who embrace nonviolence and equitable distributions of power.
相似文献
Bruce DiCristinaEmail: |
16.
Official and victimisation data show that despite falling rates for motor vehicle thefts, much of the EU ‘organized crime’
related thefts have remained almost stable. Nevertheless, the car-theft market in the EU has changed, and so has the role
of traditional destinations for stolen vehicles, such as Eastern Europe. The paper examines the demand, supply, and regulation
factors that shape the structures of the vehicle theft market in Bulgaria, and smuggling patterns and offender behaviour in
source countries, in particular Spain. We argue that such nuanced historical approach that takes into account a wider range
of factors in destination countries can help explain the recent transformations in Europe’s vehicle-theft markets.
相似文献
Tihomir BezlovEmail: |
17.
Jan Van Dijk 《Trends in Organized Crime》2007,10(4):39-56
This study develops a causal model of the independent effect of organized crime, rule of law, and corruption on national wealth.
To measure the level of organized crime a Composite Organized Crime Index (COCI) is constructed combining data on the perceived
prevalence of organized crime, unsolved homicides, grand corruption, money-laundering and the extent of the black economy,
drawing on the World Economic Forum’s annual surveys among CEOs of larger companies, the Merchant International Group’s assessments
of investment risks in 150 countries, studies by the World Bank Institute, and official crime statistics. The findings of
the explorative analysis show that a political strategy of tolerating activities of local criminal groups in the hope of beneficial
effects on the wealth of a nation is unlikely to bring the expected results. Although some types of organized crime may bring
in significant revenues, tolerating Mafia-type activities implies letting the Trojan horse of racketeering and grand corruption
into the walls of government.
相似文献
Jan Van DijkEmail: |
18.
A Developmental Approach for Measuring the Severity of Crimes 总被引:1,自引:1,他引:0
Rajeev Ramchand John M. MacDonald Amelia Haviland Andrew R. Morral 《Journal of Quantitative Criminology》2009,25(2):129-153
There is widespread agreement in criminology that some crimes are more severe than others, but precise definitions of crime
severity and straightforward methods for measuring it have been elusive. Public perceptions of crime severity and economic
estimates of crime costs to society or willingness to pay offer a variety of metrics for the public’s perceptions of severity,
but they may not accurately describe severity as reflected in offender preferences. The behavior of offenders is critical
for understanding developmental progressions in criminal careers, as one may assume that typically more severe offenses are
not undertaken until less severe crimes have been committed. In the present paper we propose an alternative metric of crime
severity, drawing on findings from developmental criminology that indicate that more severe crimes occur after less severe
crimes in the criminal life course, and a method for estimating crime severity that uses the generalized Bradley–Terry model
of multiple paired comparisons. We demonstrate this approach on two samples of youthful offenders: the National Youth Survey
and the RAND Adolescent Outcomes Project. The results suggest that sample-specific estimates of crime severity can be derived,
that these estimates provide insight into the developmental progression of crime, and that they correspond well to crime severity
rankings produced by the public.
相似文献
John M. MacDonaldEmail: |
19.
Michael Levi 《Crime, Law and Social Change》2008,49(5):365-377
This article examines the media reportage of white-collar crimes, organised crimes and cybercrimes, principally in the British
but also in the US media. It illustrates the ways in which different newspapers depict crime seriousness and how some defendants
adapt to these portrayals. It examines competing explanatory models and suggests that although reportage has an ideological
component, ‘news values’ and production pressures as well as ‘action triggers’ such as prosecutions or regulatory interventions
are important.
相似文献
Michael LeviEmail: |
20.
Jeremy Horder 《Criminal Law and Philosophy》2007,1(1):41-47
In this analysis of Marcia Baron’s account of excuses, I seek to do two
things. I try to draw out the nature of the distinction between forgiving
and excusing. I also defend the distinction between excuses (like duress),
and denials of responsibility (like insanity).
相似文献
Jeremy HorderEmail: Phone: +020-7453-1220 |