REALITY IS. . . . A RESPONSE TO MARTINDALE,TIPPINS, BEN‐PORATH,AUSTIN, AND WITTMANN

This article is written as a response to the Martindale et al. critique of the Ackerman and Pritzl (2011) child custody evaluation practices article. The Martindale et al. critique focuses on a small portion of the overall results regarding test usage and suggests that the entire article is “flawed and deficient.” However, their critique engages in confirmatory bias and exaggerated statements and ignores the overall value of the article in general. A more broad‐based explanation of the results is provided herein.     

Suspected clozapine poisoning in the UK/Eire, 1992-2003

OBJECTIVE: Toxicological analyses are often performed to investigate suspected poisoning, but the interpretation of results may not be straightforward. We studied suspected poisoning cases 1992-2003 where blood clozapine and N-desmethylclozapine (norclozapine) were measured in order to assess the relationship of these parameters to outcome. METHODS: Samples were referred from clinicians, pathologists/coroners, or via the Clozaril Patient Monitoring Service (CPMS, Novartis). Information was gathered from clinical, post-mortem, or coroners' reports. RESULTS: There were seven fatal [five male, two female; median (range) age 28 (24-41) year] and five non-fatal [four male, one female; median age 35 (26-41) year] clozapine overdoses. The median post-mortem blood clozapine and norclozapine concentrations were 8.2 (3.7-12) and 1.9 (1.4-2.4)mg/L, respectively [median clozapine:norclozapine ratio 4.4 (2.9-5.1)]. The median plasma clozapine and norclozapine concentrations (first or only sample) were 3.9 (1.7-7.0) and 0.40 (0.30-0.70)mg/L, respectively [median clozapine:norclozapine ratio 7.6 (5.3-18)] in the remainder. These overdoses were in patients who were poorly or non-adherent to clozapine, or who had taken tablets prescribed for someone else. In 54 further people who died whilst receiving clozapine [38 male, 16 female; median age 41 (22-70) year], the median post-mortem blood clozapine and norclozapine concentrations were 1.9 (0-7.7, n = 43) and 1.4 (0-6.0, n = 39)mg/L, respectively [median clozapine:norclozapine ratio 1.5 (0.4-7.6, n = 38)]. The median post-mortem increase in blood clozapine and norclozapine as compared to the most recent ante-mortem measurement was 489 (98-5,350)% and 371 (139-831)%, respectively [median sample time before death 14 (0-30, n = 21) days]. CONCLUSION: Clozapine poisoning cannot be diagnosed on the basis of blood clozapine and norclozapine concentrations alone. The analysis of ante-mortem blood specimens collected originally for white cell count monitoring and the blood clozapine:norclozapine ratio may provide additional interpretative information.