Cosmopolitan Patriotism as a Civic Ideal

Recent theoretical debates have questioned the compatibility of patriotism with global political responsibilities, as identified by cosmopolitan theory. In response, several authors claim that a cosmopolitan patriotism is both possible and desirable. In this article, we propose two desiderata for cosmopolitan patriotism as a civic ideal, which existing accounts fail to meet. First, arguments for cosmopolitan patriotism should provide an account of collective identification, supporting the relation between the actions of one's country and one's appropriate reactive attitudes. Second, such a theory should be able to explain the patriot's commitment to critical engagement with her country's actions. We then offer a critical appraisal of two accounts linking patriotism with global responsibility—Permissible Partialism and Globally Responsible Nationalism—-and demonstrate how they fall short. Finally, we propose an account of civic republican patriotism, which better explains how cosmopolitanism and patriotism can be brought together.     

Reviews

Alberto Melucci: Liberta che cambia. Una ecologia del quotidiano (Liberty that changes. An every‐day‐ecology). Edizioni Unicolpi, Milano, 1987.

Roberto Biorcio/Giovanni Lodi (eds.): La sfida verde. Il movimento ecologista in Italia. (The green challenge. The ecological movement in Italy). With an introduction by Alberto Melucci. Liviana Editrice, Padova, 1988.

Vandana Shiva: Staying Alive: Women, Ecology and Development. In the U.K., Zed Books, London. In India, Kali for Women, 1988