Toward a new theory of punishment

Criteria for a successful theory of punishment include first, that it specify a reasonable limit to punishments in particular cases, and second, that it allow benefits to outweigh costs in a penal institution.It is argued that traditional utilitarian and retributive theories fail to satisfy both criteria, and that they cannot be coherently combined so as to do so. Retributivism specifies a reasonable limit in its demand that punishment equal crime, but this limit fails to allow benefits to outweigh costs of punishing. Utilitarians demand the latter but cannot guarantee the former. Combinations continue to violate one requirement or the other.The most vulnerable element of the traditional theories is the retributive limit. An alternative is suggested according to a new but similar model of reciprocal social rights and obligations. The rights of a citizen in the moral community are considered as a package, which reverts temporarily to the community in trusteeship when the citizen seriously violates the rights of others. The community must exercise the least restraint necessary to protect others until the full package of rights can be restored to the individual.Problems for this new theory and advantages over alternative models are discussed in the final section.     

Eisenhower reconsidered

He is also a Russell Conwell Fellow at Temple University, where he is a doctoral candidate in history.     

Exploitation, Extortion and Oppression

Exploitation, extortion and oppression describe unjust social arrangements that ought to be changed. The concept of exploitation is particularly associated with Marx's critique of capitalism, and the term 'extortion' sometimes designates the injustice of feudalism. The distinctions between these concepts can be clarified using the framework of rational-choice theory. Oppression is a situation of unfair exclusion (from resources, or utilities more generally). Exploitation is the unfair use by one person of the excluded situation of another. Extortion involves the deliberate creation of an exploiting situation. The relation of these phenomena to coercion is a logical one only in the case of extortion: coercion being necessary to extortion.     

Technical expertise and risk conflict: An institutional study of the British compulsory seat belt debate

Controversy and public conflict seem to be inevitable features of contemporary risk debates. In the face of such disputes, one common response has been to characterise disagreement as a disparity between expert analyses of ‘actual’ risk, and emotional ‘perceptions’ of hazard. This paper uses the example of the British policy debate over compulsory seat belt wear in order to argue that these characterisations are inaccurate and obstructive. Instead, an ‘institutional’ perspective on such issues is advocated - this perspective considers the effect of political and organisational factors in shaping the direction of public debate. The analysis here focuses particularly on expert disagreement over the likely effectiveness of seat belt laws - the debate over ‘risk compensation’ is reviewed both before and after the introduction of seat belt laws as an ‘experimental’ measure.     

Self-image in adolescents with delayed puberty and growth retardation

Fifty-six adolescents with varying combinations of pubertal delay and growth retardation were given the Offer Self-Image Questionnaire. Delay in sexual maturation by itself had no significant deleterious effect on self-image; however, growth retardation did. These results have important implications in determining indications for the endocrinological treatment of pubertal disorders.Received highest degree from University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa. Presently Child Psychiatrist, Geha Psychiatric Hospital. Main interest is adolescent psychiatry.Received highest degree from Bar Ilan University. Current research interest is psychology of the adolescent: hormones and behavior.Received highest degree from Bar Ilan University. Current research interest is psychological disturbances in short stature.Received highest degree from Sackler School of Medicine. Current research interest is growth and diabetes.