Using soft skills courses to inspire law teachers: a new methodology for a more humanistic legal education

ABSTRACT

Law schools have in recent years been engaged in a process of revising their curricula, in large part adapting to rapid changes in technology, but also in a more generalised effort to improve “teaching the law”. Yet thus far, legal pedagogy seems to focus disproportionately on the traditional model of the “thinking lawyer”, when it should equally promote the model of the “feeling lawyer”, helping students to sharpen soft skills such as empathy, integrity and problem-solving. The main claim of this paper is that law professors could begin to pay more attention to the growing importance of soft skills in legal education and preparedness for legal practice. In this direction, we propose a set of pedagogical principles revolving around four axes: compassionate, attentive, reason-based and empathetic teaching (CARE). This methodology could help law professors become more effective pedagogues. Soft skills courses constitute a well-suited vehicle for introducing these principles to law school curricula in different legal systems. By systematically incorporating them, law schools can encourage law teachers to provide a more inclusive learning environment for their students. At the same time, law teachers who implement the particular methodology can hopefully rediscover fulfilment in their teaching. Overall, teaching soft skills can significantly improve students’ and teachers’ experience in legal education.     

论阐释的有效性:“阐释循环”与钱钟书诗学

The view that “Hermeneutic Circle” is a peculiarity of Qian Zhongshu's Methodology of Poetics is called “Theory of Hermeneutic Circle.” It came into being in the 1980s and was established as a theory at the beginning of this century by its advocators. As one of the main theories in “Qian Studies”, “Theory of Hermeneutic Circle” contributes much to the study of Qian Zhongshu's specific method in poetics. Unfortunately, there are several problems in the practice of this theory. First, it ignores the validity of “Hermeneutic Circle,” which is a concept traveled in the Chinese academia from the western world. Second, it forgets that the most authoritative criterion of judging what is the proper summary of Qian's methodology is his works themselves. And thirdly, it is obviously wrong to overstate the applicability of the concept “Hermeneutic Circle” and want to summarize the whole methodology of Qian Zhongshu by using such a single term. Therefore, it may eventually lead to the magnification and invalidity of the theory.     

A Test of the Passalacqua Age at Death Estimation Method Using the Sacrum

A test of the accuracy of the Passalacqua (J Forensic Sci, 5, 2009, 255) sacrum method in a forensic context was performed on a sample of 153 individuals from the J.C.B. Grant Skeletal Collection. The Passalacqua (J Forensic Sci, 5, 2009, 255) method assesses seven traits of the sacrum using a 7‐digit coding system. An accuracy of 97.3% was achieved using the Passalacqua (J Forensic Sci, 5, 2009, 255) method to estimate adult skeletal age. On average each age estimate differed by 12.87 years from the known age. The method underestimated the age of individuals by an average of 4.3 years. An intra‐observer error of 6.6% suggests that the method can be performed with precision. Correlation and regression analysis found that the sacral traits used in the Passalacqua (J Forensic Sci, 5, 2009, 255) method did not have a strong relationship with age or an ability to strongly predict age. Overall, the method was not practical for use in a forensic context due to the broad age ranges, despite the high accuracy and low intra‐observer error.     

《晋书.刑法志》中的法哲学

《晋书·则法志》是中国法律思想史上的一部重要著作,同时也是一部集中反映中国传统法哲学的经典作品.在法本体论问题上,《晋书·;刑法志》向我们介绍了一种“整体论”的法律观,即法律是一种复合物,呈“三位一体”结构,其权威也是建立在“复合型权威”基础之上.在法认识论问题上,《晋书·刑法志》叙述了晋代的人们在“法律科学化”方面所做的种种尝试.在法律方法论上,《晋书·刑法志》表达了尽理为法、奉法循理等科学的司法理念.《晋书·刑法志》中的法哲学是一种非常先进的法哲学.     

经济分析法学方法论的贡献及局限

经济分析方法对法学方法论有一定的贡献,如为法学分析提供了一种系统的观察方法,解决了对某些法律制度存在的困惑,初步形成一套传统法学所缺少的分析体系等,但法经济学和法经济分析方法存在的一些问题,这些问题表现在其本身的研究领域界限尚不明确、法经济学将问题复杂化的同时却存在偏离经济分析基本目的的倾向、法经济学研究由于方法的高度理论化和无益于现实问题的解决以及法经济学的工具理性倾向等;经济分析方法在中国法学研究中可能面临一些新问题。     

哲学视野中的制度演化规律研究

哲学视野中的制度演化规律是指制度在演化过程中所反映出来的一些规律性的现象。制度演化大体遵循这样三条规律:路径依赖、量变中的质变和渐变中的突变并存、客观必然性和现实可能性的统一。     

科学发展观是指导发展的世界观和方法论的集中体现

科学发展观是指导发展的世界观和方法论的集中体现。科学发展观深刻回答了实践主体与客体的正确关系,展示了马克思主义实践观的新要求;科学界定了生产力的新内涵,对马克思主义生产力观作出了新的理论概括;深刻回答了发展依靠人民,发展成果人民共享的问题,拓展了马克思主义群众观的新视野;深刻回答了以人为本、全面协调可持续发展问题,展示了马克思主义方法论的新水平。     

后现代主义之石：可攻民法方法论之玉

后现代主义形成于20世纪60年代,尽管它有光“破”不“立”的缺陷,但其注重多样性、差异性、特别性,强调多元性、联系和整体有机性,对于避免以往民法学研究中的片面化局限,提供了可资借鉴的更具包容性的多向度、多视角的研究方法。民法学研究当采多学科、大整合的方法,赋较具综合性的民法哲学和民法文化学以应有的位置。     

美国两次德育改革的方法论启示

20世纪初和70年代美国相继进行了两次全局性的大规模德育改革。两次改革发展的主线和焦点是直接法和间接法的争论与反复。美国德育方法改革的历史为我们探索道德教育方法提供了诸多有益的启示。     

文化人类学研究与旅游规划

盖茨(Getz)提出一种整合的系统模型作为旅游规划的框架,它可以避免旅游规划以往只关注发展的倾向,也有利于旅游研究的理论发展。这一模型的理论基础是整体系统理论,其递进关系为:理解控制旅游系统;形成目标;制定达成目标的具体项目;选择并评价可能的规划;实施;评价和反馈。