Partisanship and independence: the peculiar moralism of American politics |
| |
Authors: | Nancy L Rosenblum |
| |
Institution: | 1. Department of Government, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USAnrosenblum@gov.harvard.edu |
| |
Abstract: | Against the background of historical antipartyism in practice and in democratic theory, and with a focus on American political thought, this paper takes issue with contemporary arguments that value the political identity ‘Independent’ and disparage partisanship. A typology of ‘Independent’ is offered and both empirical and moral claims about the superiority of Independent voters are rebutted, with particular focus on the ‘weightlessness’ of Independents. The reasons to appreciate the moral distinctiveness of partisanship for democracy are set out: commitment to political pluralism, to regulated political rivalry, and to shifting responsibility for governing. Inclusiveness, comprehensiveness, and compromisingness set the contours for an ethic of partisanship. |
| |
Keywords: | partisan partisanship independent ethics of partisanship democratic theory antipartyism |
|
|