在规则秩序与自由裁量权之间——评《转变中的法律与社会：迈向回应型法》

毫无疑问,在一个复杂多变的社会中,如果自由裁量权受到法律的过度控制,社会问题将难以解决。美国学者诺内特和塞尔兹尼克在其《转变中的法律与社会：迈向回应型法》中,提出了＂回应型法＂的概念,旨在放松法律规则对自由裁量权的束缚和限制。他们主张：为了回应变化着的现实世界,包括程序在内的法律形式主义能够被放弃。文章认为,这将必然导致自由裁量权的滥用。因此,应在规则与自由裁量权之间维持平衡。

Between Rules and Discretion:Review on Law and Society in Transition:Toward Responsive Law

There is no doubt that the social problems will be difficult to solve in a complex and changing society if discretion is unduly controlled by law..Americans scholars,P.Nonet and P.Selznick in their Law and Society in Transition:toward Responsive Law,put forward the concept of responsive law,which is aimed at loosening the tight rein of legal rules on discretion.They argue that legal formalism including procedure;can be abandoned in order to respond to the changing realistic world.This,in my opinion,will nec...