The Freedom of Information Act 1966–2006: A Retrospective on the Rise of Privacy Protection Over the Public Interest in Knowing What the Government's Up To

The tension between an individual's right to privacy and the public's right to obtain government-held information represents a conflict between two vital democratic values. The solution to resolving this tension lies in striking an appropriate balance between a person's need to be let alone and society's need to be informed. The crafters of the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) intended to set such a balance when they created two privacy exemptions to the statute. In instances when the government refuses to release a record on privacy grounds, then a requester may turn to the courts to interpret what the law instructs. Consequently, the judiciary has significantly shaped the contours of the FOIA over the years. This article examines whether the Supreme Court's current FOIA-related privacy framework comports with the FOIA as reflected in its legislative history.