In the mirror of the justices: Sources of greatness on the Supreme Court |
| |
Authors: | Gregory A Caldeira |
| |
Institution: | (1) Department of Political Science, The Ohio State University, 223 Derby Hall, 43210-1373 Columbus, OH |
| |
Abstract: | Few political scientists have undertaken systematic study of the determinants of greatness on the Supreme Court. In this article, I formulate and test a series of competing explanations for judicial eminence in a multivariate model. For the measure of performance on the Court, I use Blaustein and Mersky's ratings of the justices. The alternative explanations include social backgrounds, occupational experiences, political connections, experiences on the Court, and region of residence. Neither occupational experiences nor political connections have an appreciable impact on the level of achievement a justice reaches. Thus, contrary to one of the most popular hypotheses, previous judicial experience does not give an individual any advantage. Instead, in much greater measure, experiences on the Supreme Court and certain social backgrounds differentiate among the various levels of performance. In particular, the statistical analysis indicates the centrality and potency of parental status, religious affiliation, reputation as a dissenter, the number of opinions written in landmark cases, holding the office of chief justice, years of service, and the age of the justice at appointment. |
| |
Keywords: | |
本文献已被 SpringerLink 等数据库收录! |
|