The Intent Behind the Cryptic Concurrence That Provided a Reporter's Privilege |
| |
Authors: | Michele Bush Kimball |
| |
Institution: | Department of Communication , University of South Alabama , |
| |
Abstract: | Justice Lewis Powell wrote a concurrence in Branzburg v. Hayes that, despite a majority opinion to the contrary, eventually provided room for journalists to claim a privilege against testifying in grand jury proceedings. For decades, scholars and judges have questioned what Justice Powell meant by his concurrence and whether he, in fact, supported a reporter's right to refuse to reveal confidential information. Justice Powell's personal papers and case files, as well as those of his fellow justices, observations of one of his former law clerks, and oral arguments shed light on the reasoning behind Justice Powell's enigmatic concurrence. This article concludes that Justice Powell supported a qualified reporter's privilege, applied on a case-by-case basis. |
| |
Keywords: | |
|
|