试论国内仲裁司法监督的范围

独立性和一裁终局性体现了仲裁制度的基本精神,仲裁裁决由于其准司法特点,也必然受制于国家司法权力的监督和制约。我国《仲裁法》所建构的对国内仲裁进行实体性和程序性全面司法监督的体制,在现实中存在监督不当的可能,更重要的是与仲裁制度本质以及与民事诉讼机制平衡关系等存在抵触。从制度构建的角度来讲,应改而确立司法对仲裁的程序性监督机制,保证司法机制和仲裁机制在民商事纠纷处理机制上的平衡关系。

On The Ranges of Justice Supervising Civil Arbitration

Independence and first award being the final are fundamental characters of arbitration system. The arbitration awards should be supervised by judicial power because of its quasi-judicial character. But it may be inappropriate that the arbitration awards are supervised by justice not only on substances but on procedures. To keep the balance of justice and arbitration on dealing with civil and commercial disputes ,the system should be established that justice can only supervise arbitration on procedures.