实践理性与疑难案件的法律适用——基于“实践法律观”的一种补充

当前在疑难案件中,法律的正确适用是司法的核心问题及公众关注的焦点。但由于＂法律观＂的差别,使得疑难案件的法律适用存在诸多问题。从学术史及方法论角度看,学者们处理疑难案件有各种方法,但最终都依赖对＂法＂的正确认识及案件事实与法律规范之间的关系的澄清。只有在个案事实与规范的融贯中,在实践理性理论框架内,通过类推等方法,发现、鉴别法律规范才能使疑难案件得以恰当处理。

Practical Reason and its Legal Application in Dealing with Difficult Cases

One of the key issues in China＇s socialism legal practice is how law is properly enforced in judicial adjudication,especially in difficult cases where the proper enforcement of law is the core issue and attracts public attention.However,due to the different views of law,there exist many problems in legal application when we deal with difficult cases.From the perspective of academic history and methodology,scholars propose different means to deal with difficult cases.However,they all rely on the proper recognition of law and the clear relationship between cases and legal regulations.Within the framework of practical reason theory,difficult cases can be properly handled via the method of analogy.