人身伤害重新鉴定的困惑与出路

刑事诉讼法和司法解释对人身伤害重新鉴定立法位置安排的不当和程序设计的缺失,遭到了鉴定实践的抗争,默默演变为不断重复鉴定的制造源。因此,应当完善人身伤害重新鉴定的启动程序,经过文证审查的过滤,建构专家委员会的终结性复核鉴定制度,并通过诉讼程序消解鉴定障碍,达到公正选择适用重新鉴定程序规则的目的。

Perplexity and Approach on Re- evaluation of Personal Injury

The malpractice of legislation and lack of procedure in criminal law of procedure and judicial interpretation meet the attack from practice, so that they continually make multiple re-evaluations. We should improve the opening procedure of re-evaluation about personal injury, restructure rehearing evaluation system of expert committee after written review, eliminate evaluation obstacle by the procedure and achieve the goal that we could justly choose the procedural rules of re-evaluation.