对事故调查组的质疑

组成事故调查组是我国上级行政机构行使行政监督权的具体方式,具有一定合理性;但从法治的角度进行考察,具有重大缺陷:启动具有一定偶然性,不具备足够的中立性,调查和裁断能力值得怀疑,程序不公开,调查结论缺乏可救济性,容易导致避重就轻、以行政处分规避刑事责任,实际上造成行政权对司法权的排斥和侵占,违背了邓小平同志的刑事法制思想.应当在以下方面对我国的事故调查组机制进行改造:明确划分事故调查组的权限,确立事故调查的正当程序,实现司法最终解决.

Queries about the Accident Investigation Group

To set up an accident investigation group is a concrete method that the higher authorities use their administrative supervisory power,and it is reasonable to some extent.But from the angle of rule of law view,it has many drawbacks.In order to reform the accident investigation mechanism,it is suggested that the power limit of the accident investigation group should be clearly divided,the due process of accident investigation should be established and the judicial final settlement principle should be realized.