Delicate balance or creative conflict?

In this issue Andrés Guadamuz explains the recent troubledhistory of the attempts that have been made to ensure the harmoniousoperation of Europe's software patent laws, and of the sad fateof those attempts. There is something paradoxical about thefact that the attempts at reform were scotched by two opposingcamps consisting of those who stood to gain most from thosereforms: on the one side those who want strong software patentsand on the other those who want no patents at all. At