210例司法精神病学鉴定案例分析

作者对210例司法精神病学鉴定案例进行分析。该组刑事案例以凶杀居首位,被鉴定人以患精神分裂症为多。鉴定结论评为无责任能力者占41.6％。案件中受害者以精神发育迟缓、正处于发病期的精神分裂症或情感性精神病的女性患者(78.4％)被奸污为多。经随访司法部门的最后处理结果和我们的鉴定结论意见较为一致。

ANALYSIS OF 210 CASES SUBMITTED TO FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC ASSESSMENT

210 criminal cases submitted to forensic psychiatric assessment were analyzed. Among 210 assessed subjects, 173 (82.4%) were defendants and 37 (17.6%) were victims. Crimes committed by 173 assessed defendants included homicide (59.4%), politic aggression (6.9%), raps (6.4%), stealing (6.4%), hurt (5.8%), arson (4.0%), robbery (2.3%), rogue (2.3), and others (3.5%). Among 173 defendants, 47 were assessed as schizophrenia, 11 paraniod psychosis, 2 affective psychosis, 12 epileptic disorders, 40 other psychoses, 18 mental retardation, 2 neurosis, 16 personality disorders, 2 acute drunkenness, and 23 without mental disorders. Among 37 victims, 16 were assessed as mental retardation, 4 Schizophrenia, 5 affective psychosis, 4 neurosis, and 1 without mental disorders. 78.4% victims were raped. As for responsibility of the defendants, 41.0% were assessed as no responsibility, 23.9% limited responsibility, and 35.1% full responsibility.The follow up results showed high agreement between the conclusions of forensic assessment and the sentences of courts.