保证期间的本体论批判

保证期间是我国保证制度中最具争议的法律概念之一。当用法学本体论的方法对其进行批判分析时,会发现保证期间是个难以自圆其说的多余概念。首先,保证期间缩减了保证期限的概念范围;其次,混淆了保证期间与保证责任期间的本质区别;第三,保证期间是把一个概念正反两方面的命题揉在一起的错误概念;第四,有关保证期间的法律性质的界定永远在一个圆圈里打转,无法自拔。要消除保证期间带来的矛盾和烦恼,只有取消它。

Criticizing the Ontology of the Guaranty Period

When using a critical analysis method of legal ontology,we will know that the guaranty period is difficult to justify the extra concept.Firsly,the guaranty period reduces the warranty period concept range;Secondly,the confusion of the guaranty period and responsibility of e guaranty period.Thirdly,guaranty period is the concept of positive and negative aspects;Finally,the legal nature of the guaranty period is always defined in a circle round and round.To eliminate the conflicts and troubles caused by guara...