论刑事裁判文书说理与司法公信力

刑事裁判文书说理主要包括定性论证、量刑论证、总结性意见和对控辩双方不同意见的采纳说明以及引用法律条文等内容。评价刑事裁判文书说理的优劣可从正确性、针对性、平衡性等方面进行。法官后语、附案件裁判所依据的法律条文、结案报告书论文化、规范说理制度等方式可以有效地辅助刑事裁判文书说理。加强裁判文书说理是提高司法公信力的切入点;加强裁判文书说理可以提高裁判质量,维护司法权威;加强裁判文书说理可以提高法官的素养和自律力。

ON Criminal Justice Instrument Argument and the Credibility of Judicial

The criminal justice instrument argument include qualitative argument,sentencing argument,the adoption of different opinions and citing law provisions.Evaluating the argument can be from accuracy,relevance and balance.The Judge afterword,attaching to the legal provisions,the final report on the culture,and establishing the reasoning system can effectively assist the argument.Strengthen the argument will improve the credibility of justice and the referee quality,safeguard judicial authority and contribute literacy and self-discipline of judges.