我国刑事诉讼中公检法三机关互相关系原则之考察

公检法三机关互相关系原则是我国宪法层面的刑事诉讼基本原则,在刑事诉讼实践中的作用不可低估。但该原则也存在着一些不科学性和缺失,主要表现在互相配合与实现刑事司法公正价值机制相冲突,妨碍人民法院在刑事司法中的中立性和独立地位;互相制约没有明显的主次之分,过于强调“平分秋色”而忽略了“递进制约”关系,抑制了检察、审判职能的发挥。对此,有必要予以科学的分析,并给予规范和整合。

A Review on the Principle of the Relations between Police, Procuratorate and Court

The principle of the relations between police,procuratorate and court plays an important role in practice since it is a basic principle of criminal litigation at the level of China's constitution.But it has some shortcomings,such as: three organs' cooperation conflicts with judicial justice's realization and hinders the court's neutrality and independence in criminal justice;there's no obvious distinction between the primary and the secondary in mutual restriction,so that it restrains the procuratorial work and judgement.Thus,it requires a scientific analyse,standardization and integration.