Assembling noncitizenship through the work of conditionality |
| |
Authors: | Patricia Landolt Luin Goldring |
| |
Affiliation: | 1. Department of Sociology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canadalandolt@utsc.utoronto.ca;3. Department of Sociology, York University, Toronto, Canada |
| |
Abstract: | AbstractWe develop a framework for understanding noncitizenship that combines attention to systemic processes with interest in contingency and indeterminacy in the production and substantive practices associated with noncitizen legal status categories and trajectories. We argue that noncitizenship is a dynamic, multi-scalar assemblage that brings together disparate elements in patterned and changing ways. Individuals and institutions generate the formal and substantive systems that confer or deny noncitizens the formal and substantive right to be present in a country and/or to access entitlements. Noncitizens exercise agency in choosing to make claims (or choosing to not make claims) to substantive rights, and the individuals and institutions with which they interact may facilitate or hinder such claims-making. In this process, social actors are enacting conditionality; they are working to meet the conditions required to maintain presence and access. Discretion, migrant agency, unequal social interactions, and social learning unfold over time and can generate a range of experiences of noncitizenship and legal status trajectories. These do not necessarily conform to expected pathways and timelines, and may combine access to various resources and public goods in variable and contingent ways. We illustrate the framework with data from research conducted in Toronto. |
| |
Keywords: | Noncitizenship assemblage conditionality contingency theory Canada |
|
|