浅析我国仲裁司法监督的范围

目前,我国对内外仲裁的司法监督实行＂双轨制＂,其涉外仲裁裁决仅涉及审查和监督程序运作,国内仲裁裁决则涉及实体和程序两方面的审查。针对仲裁监督的范围,学界在＂程序监督论＂和＂全面监督论＂的问题上一直存有分歧。本文对比分析了这两大观点,并借鉴了英美法系和大陆法系国家的立法规定,提出了完善我国仲裁司法监督范围的几点建议。

On the Scope of Judicial Supervision of China＇s Arbitration

The ＂dual system＂ is currently applied to domestic and foreign arbitration in China.For foreign arbitral award,reviewing and monitoring procedures are operated only,while for domestic arbitral award involves reviewing both substantive and procedural aspects of supervision.For the scope of judicial supervision arbitration,there have been differences in theoretical fields in issues of＂procedural oversight＂ and ＂overall supervision＂ that discussions have been hold between the two.Based on the analysis of these two perspectives and the comparison of common law and civil law provisions on national legislation,this paper puts forward some suggestions for improving the scope of judicial supervision of China＇s arbitration.