互易毒品行为定性“相对说”之提倡——兼与孙万怀教授商榷

互易毒品与贩卖毒品之间是一种交叉关系,将互易毒品行为一律不作为犯罪处理或一律作为犯罪处理,在方法论上存在错误,由此而划定的互易毒品的内涵,也为罪刑法定原则所不容。根据互易毒品的形式与实质,结合现行刑法关于涉毒犯罪的规定,确立＂相对说＂将成立买卖关系的高纯度与低纯度毒品、硬性毒品与软性毒品以及相同纯度但数量不等毒品间的互易,作为贩卖毒品罪处理,其他情况的互易毒品行为不作为犯罪处理,才是合适的。

The Relative Theory in the Qualitative of Drug Exchange Be Advocated

The act of drug trafficking and drug exchange is a relationship of part overlapping.It is wrong to think all kinds of drug exchange as crime or not.This article holds that it is appropriate to determine the nature of drug exchange depending the form and essential of the drug exchange,as well as consideration the regulation of criminal code about drug crime.Therefore,we may decide that some kinds of drug exchange constitutes crime of drug trafficking,however,and some not,on the basis of drug purity and the t...