语义学之刺及其解决方案

德沃金转向的重要前提是所谓的“语义学之刺”。语义学之刺的理论构建及其争议,让理论性争议的理论解释问题重新浮现。审视两种语义学之刺的解决方案,蕴含着何种解决方案更佳的理论争鸣。德沃金的理解以及另一种可能的思考,揭示出理论争鸣的评价标准是相对的启示。

On the Semantic Sting and Its Solutions

The important premise of Dworkin’s interpretive turn is the so-called "the semantic sting". The theoretical construction and disputes of the semantic sting makes interpretation issues of theoretical disagreement recur.The exploration of two solutions to the semantic sting implies a controversy over which is a better option.Dworkin’s understanding and another possible perception indicate that the evaluation criterion of theoretical debates is relative.